Monday, January 13, 2020

THE USS ENTERPRISE AS A UFO


Episode Title:  Tomorrow is Yesterday

Air Date: 1/26/1967

Written by Dorothy C. Fontana

Directed by Michael O'Herlihy

Cast: William Shatner as Captain James T. Kirk    Leonard Nimoy as Lieutenant Commander Spock             DeForest Kelley as Dr. Leonard H. McCoy AKA “Bones”              James Doohan  as Lieutenant Commander Montgomery Scott AKA “Scotty”        George Takei  as Lieutenant  Hikaru Sulu              Nichelle Nichols as Lieutenant Nyota Uhura          John Winston as Lieutenant Kyle           Eddie Paskey as Lieutenant Leslie                 Bill Blackburn as Engineer           Frank Da Vinci as Lieutenant Brent                      Sherri Townsend as unnamed Crewwoman              Roger Perry as Captain John Christopher           Hal Lynch as unnamed Air Police Staff Sergeant                   Richard Merrifield as unnamed Technician                Ed Peck as Lieutenant Colonel Fellini        Mark Dempsey as  Air Force Captain   Jim Spencer as Air Force Policeman     Majel Barrett as Enterprise Computer 

Ships: USS Enterprise NCC-1701

Planets:  Earth

My Spoiler filled summary and review:  At a U.S. Air Force base a radar technician notices a boogie on their radar screen and notifies his superior.  The officer responds by calling it in so they can send a plane up there.  A plane is dispatched and when the pilot catches up to the blip in the sky he sees the UFO and it is the USS Enterprise.
What is that?

On the bridge of the Enterprise we see the crew picking themselves up after what appears to be quite an ordeal.  Kirk explains to his Captain's Log that the Enterprise was caught unexpectedly in the gravity of an uncharted black star.   In order to escape from certain death they had attempted to break away at warp speed.  They were successful but it sent them flying off in an uncontrolled direction.  It appears they are lucky at first for they quickly discover that they are in the atmosphere of the planet Earth.  However when Lt. Uhura tries to communicate with Starfleet she discovers that the Starfleet signal is dead but she is getting a lot of radio traffic.  They tune into the radio and discover that they accidentally traveled back to Earth’s past.  They are now in the late 1960s or as people who were watching this episode when it debuted would have thought: the crew of the Enterprise has come back to today.
It's big!
As the 20th century aircraft approaches their starship, Spock expressed concern that this plane may be carrying nuclear warheads and if they were to hit them with one could damage the ship so severely it may be impossible to repair and present conditions.  This shows a hole in Mr. Spock’s Earth history knowledge although there were nuclear weapons at this time they were hardly standard weaponry one would see on a regular US aircraft. Their current damage prevents them from pulling away to quickly so Kirk decides the best thing to do would be to use their tractor beam on the plane.   The aircraft is not capable of dealing the strain of tractor beam however and it begins to breakup.  Kirk orders for the pilot to be beamed aboard.  Lt. Kyle, who is the transporter chief, successfully rescues the Air Force officer. 


Two men now both out of time!

The pilot introduces himself as Captain John Christopher; Captain Kirk wants to make this pilot feel home and comfortable.  Although the Air Force Captain finds Kirk story to be somewhat wild he nevertheless has to believe it seeing as he is actually on the starship that he himself had also seen from the outside.  They give Captain Christopher something else to wear besides his flight suit.  This an interesting part instead of giving him some civilian garb to wear they actual give him a Starfleet uniform the rank insignia of a lieutenant.  This makes some sense because a Starfleet lieutenant and Air Force captain would be equivalent in rank.
This image is destined to become a meme of a meme! One of the world's most popular.

Mr. Spock has decided now is a good time to drop some bad news, since Captain Christopher now has knowledge of the future that if such knowledge were to get into the wrong hands it could wipe out of existence the reality to which they come from.  Therefore, Spock concludes,  it would be dangerous to allow Captain Christopher to return to where he came as he could disrupt all of the future that must come.  Spock consulted the record to make sure that there was no significant contribution from Captain Christopher therefore removing him from history and taking him with them back to the 23rd century is least dangerous outcome.

 As expected Captain Christopher objects to this.  Christopher tries to escape only to be taken down but one of the greatest fighters the galaxy himself: Captain Kirk.  While Captain Christopher is sulking from his defeat at the hands of Kirk in sick bay, Mr. Spock arrives to let them know he’s made a slight error.  Although he found no significant contribution Captain Christopher it turns out that Captain Christopher’s unborn son Col. Sean Jeffrey Christopher is destined to lead an expedition to Saturn.  So now he has to go back.
The Staff Sargent may have beaten off more than he can chew.

There still some things that needs to be cleaned up for example the Air Force now had the wreckage of Captain Christopher’s plane with photos and information taken from it.  Captain Christopher asked to go along with the away team to retrieve the information but is refused on the grounds that they can’t take the risk of anything happening to him.  Disappointed Christopher still draws them a map of the base.  Kirk beams down with Mr. Sulu to the Air Force Base to get the film. They quickly find what they are looking for but they themselves are discovered by an Air Force security staff sergeant who gets the drop on them.  When checking out Captain Kirk’s communicator the Staff Sergeant accidentally arranges for himself to beamed aboard the Enterprise.  While there the military policeman stands mostly frozen unable to comprehend what is happening to him.
See?

With security guard out of the way Kirk and Sulu continue to gather the evidence.  Then more security people arrive so Kirk decides to cause a distraction allowing Lt. Sulu to beam up with the necessary information.  Is curious to why it was that way not the other way around seeing as Kirk is the captain and all.  You would think that Sulu should take the fall for him.  However that discounts Captain Kirk’s adventurous spirit, not to mention the fact he’s such a peerless fighter that when he engages all three Air Force personnel he mostly beats them with ease.  It is only after a gun is pulled that Captain Kirk surrenders.
Lucky we had the gun or he would have continued to beat us!

Backup on the Enterprise Mr. Spock is pleased with Mr. Sulu’s success at bringing up all the evidence.  Now they have to mount a successful rescue Captain Kirk and this time Captain Christopher convinces them take him on the away mission.  Mr. Spock , Sulu, and Christopher all go down to rescue Kirk.

Kirk is presently being interrogated by the base commander—because Kirk isn’t the only commanding officer likes to get his hands dirty—this makes for some interesting exchanges between the two of them.  It is short-lived though when Kirk is quickly rescued.  Christopher attempts to escape again but is stopped with a quick Vulcan nerve pinch.
Not so fast!

 As they return to the Enterprise everything gets resolved there relatively quickly.  Mr. Scott and Mr. Spock work together to find way to return the ship to their time.  They suggest a highly risky procedure in which they use our star, Sol, to re-create the time warp.  As they loop around our star at warp speed they will begin traveling through time.  First it will propel them slightly farther backward just a few weeks and then forward toward their own time period.  The danger is when they pull the stop at the 23rd century, Mr. Scott explains that it has the potential to fly the ship apart.  Despite the risk there is an added bonus they can return their two guests back to where they belong by beaming them into themselves.  They performed the highly risky maneuver without anything going wrong and all is restored to normal the end of the episode.

Additional thoughts: The crew of the Enterprise gets their first time travel episode.  Yes, technically speaking they had their first time travel experience way back in “The Naked Time” and it was mentioned in the previous episode, but this was the first episode dedicated specifically towards time travel.  This was a good fun episode with lots of interesting character moments.  I love when Dr. McCoy suggested to Captain Kirk that maybe they should try to come up with some sort plan in case they can’t go back to their own time.  That’s Dr. McCoy for you always thinking of the worst case scenario.

In a TV series that is based hundreds of years in the future the viewer naturally starts to wonder what would happen if these amazing future people came back to our time.  When this episode was written “our time” meant 1966-1967.  This episode delivers with the crew of the Enterprise coming back to the current era.   In a way it was also little disappointing however because despite being back in the 1960s they never do anything in the 1960s.  You think the studio would want them go out and interact with the present seeing as how cheap they could make it.  You don’t have to design special sets to make up some alien world; you can film characters walking down a normal street engaging with everyday humans.  Maybe the writers were afraid that they would have to encounter some society’s problems that we had in the 1960s that they preferred to tackle by metaphor alone.

I really love the fact that Captain Kirk and his crew have now twice by complete accident while trying to escape some other disaster stumbled across time travel.  I mean what luck, to twice in your career discover something that should be impossible as possible. Just doing that once would get you in the record book but twice is certainly something else.  This would be the equivalent of an army officer during the US Civil War trying escape an ambush by suddenly discovering flight by complete accident; twice.
 
Since—as I just explained—this is their first time travel adventure, we can forgive Captain Kirk and Mr. Spock for their colossal errors in judgment in this episode.  Kirk beams a 20th century man onto his ship and his first instinct is to give him a tour without once stopping the think of how this could be potentially effecting the timeline.  Then you have Mr. Spock who objected when it was too late, after the genie was already out of the bottle so speak with Kirk having given this tour to the reluctant guest.  Then Mr. Spock suggests these rather drastic measures without taking account what his disappearance could have on future offspring not to mention the butterfly effect.  I expect Kirk and Spock to be smarter than this, but as it’s the first time travel adventure so I am going to let it slide.

The biggest issue I have is the end makes no sense.  It also invalidates an early part of this adventure.   If the Enterprise crew can just erase their presence there and even restore the reluctant guests to their place in time without the memory of the future,  then Kirk was captured and nearly imprisoned for lengthy prison sentence all for no real reason whatsoever.  Not to mention I don’t see how using the transporter enables you to beam someone into themselves and have both the past and present selves not be killed.   It also made unnecessary drama; we don’t need Captain Christopher and the police sergeant to make their final trip exciting.  We saw what the bridge of the ship look like after the first trip through time. Clearly if they go back and try to do it again they are risking a lot and this is especially true seeing as their first trip was a freak of nature.  They should’ve just done a Vulcan mind meld on the two 20th-century humans on board causing them to forget, and then did their temporal loop around the sun.

To end on a positive note, seeing as I did like the episode, I love the classical line near the beginning of the episode.  Kirk says to Spock, “Moon landings? That was in the late 1960s.”  To which Spock replies, “Apparently Captain, so are we.”  There is so much to dissect from that line.  Of course the literal story meaning that the Enterprise had traveled back to the 1960s.  There is also the deeper meaning: Star Trek is a product of the sixties, and that is so important to remember while watching the reruns.  

FINAL GRADE: 4 of 5

No comments:

Post a Comment